Friday, November 13, 2009

A Change in Emphasis

The West Bend library controversy, so far as I can tell, is over, since the primary censor has moved on to preventing health care reform, keeping Wisconsin sex education in the dark ages, and otherwise defending America from godless Communism.  The other library challenges I've tracked recently (Cheshire, Leesburg, and Jessamine County) each seem to have reached some kind of stalemate or impasse.  So now is a good time to regroup.

I had documented a good part of the West Bend controversy on www.BannedInWestBend.info, and have been wondering what I should do with the site as that particular controversy fades into oblivion.  I've decided to keep the site active, but to change its focus.  This seems quite appropriate, since for me the phrase "Banned In West Bend" is no longer a reference to one particular situation, but has become a label for misguided attempts at censorship in any library anywhere.  So I've revamped the website to that end, reducing the West Bend library issue to just one aspect of a broader set of information about censorship in public libraries.

I don't claim any special expertise, but I have chosen to document what I learned.  Most importantly, I want to leave some easily accessible information that might help others who find themselves in the position of having to fight censorship in public libraries.  So the website now has:
At present, the site also has varying degrees of detail on four separate examples of attempted censorship in public libraries:
I have to give special thanks to Dan/SafeLibraries, more than any other individual or group, for making www.BannedInWestBend.info what it is.  Without his endless deluge of disinformation, I never would have dug so deeply into Free Speech law, nor read so many fine and challenged books.  However useful information on my website might be, it is there largely in response to him.

The Censorfreelib blog has already been opening up to the broader topic, without anything all that noticeable, beyond some minor reformatting installed over the last day or two.


Thursday, November 12, 2009

SafeLibraries Twists Facts Again, and Bans NonCensor for Catching Him in the Act

In today's post, SafeLibraries once again twists facts and hopes nobody notices.  I caught him red handed, and now he's banned me from his blog.  As usual, he claims I am engaging in a personal attack, which I most definitely am not.  An ad hominem or personal attack seeks to damage a speaker's reputation rather than dealing directly with his evidence, in hopes that the listener will then pay less attention to the evidence.  It is NOT an ad hominem or personal attack to point out a factual error in someone's evidence.  If a speaker's reputation is damaged by being caught in fabricating evidence, that is the speaker's fault, not the fault of the person pointing out the fabrication.

The exact sentence in question, cut and pasted here from SafeLibrarie's blog post, is:
As Judith Krug of the American Library Association said, "Parents who would tell their children not to read Playboy 'don't really care about their kids growing up and learning to think and explore.'"
He has here altered the meaning of the source he is quoting from, which is a 1995 issue of Focus on the Family Citizen (I have carried his link forward into the above text).  The original source makes it clear that Krug's only original words were the quote within the quote: 'don't really care about their kids growing up and leaning to think and explore.'  SafeLibraries subtly rewrote the original, and in so doing put words in Judith Krug's mouth that the original makes clear she never actually spoke.  Judith Krug did not say the words "Parents who would tell their children not to read Playboy." Those are the words of the Focus on the Family Citizen magazine. This is quite clear from the caption under the picture at the bottom of page 3 of the magazine issue (click the link above).


To be clear, there is only one possible way to interpret the sentence SafeLibraries wrote, which is that all of the words within the outer quotes were Ms. Krug's own.  The only way a reader would discover otherwise would be to click on the link, find the quote in the original, and read the original sentence with careful attention to its punctuation.


My experience has been that this is quite typical of SafeLibraries' twisting art.  There's always a small change in wording here, a discrepancy ignored there, a possibility recast as a probability, a probability recast as a certainty.  In this case, he changes whose mouth which words came out of, a detail which can be critical in debates such as these.  After all such subtleties in one of SafeLibraries' articles are added up, we find that the reader has been allowed to take home a message that is radically different from the facts.  


In general, I doubt these shifts of meaning are accidental.  I think SafeLibraries knowingly modifies the facts to conform to the message he has decided in advance that they will carry.  I could believe today's gaffe was just an error if I didn't have so much of his history to work with, and if his obvious writing ability didn't make it so clear that he actually does know the rules.


I responded to his post:



Anybody out there know what the late Ms. Krug's actual words were in the above quotation? Only the words within the inner quotes ('don't really care about their kids growing up and learning to think and explore') are Ms. Krug's words, and that is only a sentence fragment.
The words in the outer quote ("Parents who would tell their children not to read Playboy") are the words of Focus On Family Citizen magazine, not Ms. Krug. This is quite clear if locate the quote in the source SafeLibries links that quote to.
So what did she really say?


Thu Nov 12, 11:39:00 AM 2009 

He wrote back:



Well, that's why I provided the quote accurately and the source material in its entirety, as is my habit, and just for reasons such as the one Non-Censor raises.
Here is that source again:
"What Lurks in the Library? - The American Library Association Believes Children Should Have Access to All Material, No Matter How Violent or Obscene," byScott DeNicola, (Focus on the Family) Citizen, 18 September 1995.
"Parents who would tell their children not to read Playboy 'don't really care about their kids growing up and learning to think and explore.'"


Thu Nov 12, 11:55:00 AM 2009

I Clarified:


You did provide the quote, per se, accurately. But the sentence you wrote was not accurate. You wrote:

As Judith Krug of the American Library Association said, "Parents who would tell their children not to read Playboy 'don't really care about their kids growing up and learning to think and explore.'"
Your sentence, as ordered and punctuated puts exact words into the mouth of Ms. Krug, which, in fact, she did not utter.

And in spite of the care I took to focus on exact words and facts, and to avoid issues of personalities, SafeLibraries' response was:

I provided complete punctuation. The double quotes and the single quotes are present and reflect the original. I provided the entire document that was the source of the quote. The quote is obviously not mine, and the portion that is Judith Krug's is obvious as well. I constructed the sentence in the normal manner that anyone would construct such sentences. Anyone can read the source and decide for himself if the author's sentence accurately presents the truth of the matter reported by the author.


Yet you are saying I'm putting words in someone's mouth. 


This is an example of your turning almost every issue into one where I am the target of your attacks. The NCAC literally pushing porn while at the same time advising local communities and school districts about "censorship," that you don't comment about. I suppose that is acceptable to you, but my typical use of punctuation is not.
In this case, you are cleverly accusing me.... No. You are expressly saying "Your sentence, as ordered and punctuated puts exact words into the mouth of Ms. Krug, which, in fact, she did not utter."
I followed all rules humanly possible to follow to ensure the quote was as accurately quoted as possible and the source was as accessible as possible. I wrote it no differently than someone else would have written it under the circumstances.
Yet here you are, Non-Censor, telling me, telling my audience, "Your sentence, as ordered and punctuated puts exact words into the mouth of Ms. Krug, which, in fact, she did not utter." In other words, I'm a liar and can't be trusted. Is there any other interpretation? It is a regular theme of yours in attack after attack.
Non-Censor, your comments are largely ad hominem in nature, have been made over a long period of time, and serve only to detract from the issue at hand. I have worked with you to change that, and for a blog post or two, you actually truly contributed for the first time, and I even pointed that out to you, even getting positive attention from the ALA. Ithanked you for that.
However, given the above and even despite my removing your persistent personal attacks from my previous blog post, you come back here and claim I am making things up despite my accurate and proper use of punctuation and link to a reliable source, and my sentence structure that anyone would have used without being accused of intentionally lying.
At some point one has to give up on a lost cause. Getting you to address issues instead of attacking me personally with falsity like illustrated by your current comments has been sincerely attempted by me, but I have obviously failed.
Sadly, I do not have the time to evaluate and respond to your persistent, personal attacks any longer. Please do not further write on my blog posts. If you do, I will remove your comments ASAP given the above circumstances and the obviousness that your attacks will never end no matter what I do, sad as that truly makes me. Do not write on my blog posts any further.


Thu Nov 12, 02:35:00 PM 2009

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

SafeLibraries Says the ALA is Strongarming Nicholasville, Kentucky!

Since SafeLibraries has censored me on his own blog, I’ll have to take the unusual step of responding to his disinformation on my own.  On Monday, November 9th, he posted an article about the firing of two desk attendants at the Jessamine County public library in Nicholasville, KY.  “ALA Controls Nicholasville,” his headline shouts.  Let's take a look at how he’s twisted facts into delusion yet again.

He claims that the employees were fired “overnight,” even though the Lexington Herald-Leader article he himself cites states clearly that they had been interfering with library policy for a year. 

He claims that citizens who came to a library meeting to discuss the firing and the appropriateness of library materials were unfairly silenced because they weren’t on the agenda.  He refuses to accept the plain fact that “not on the agenda” means no more and no less than “not on the agenda.”

He writes “the library actually refuses to comply with the citizens.”  How so?  He offers no details nor a shred of evidence that this is so.  What did the citizens actually ask for?  How many asked for it?  Was a vote taken?  Was it a majority opinion?  By what legal process was some will of the people established?  He’s just casting groundless aspersions.

In his view, the problem here is the American Library Association, which is somehow overriding community wishes.  He offers not the slightest bit of evidence that this took place.  The ALA is no more than a professional and advisory organization.  It has no regulatory or compulsory authority over anybody or anything.  Firing these employees was entirely the decision of the local library and library board, not of the ALA.  

SafeLibraries is obsessed with the ALA, which he claims is imposing some kind of arbitrary ideology on libraries everywhere.  He refuses to accept the fact the ALA policies are firmly grounded in Free Speech law.  When I asked pointed questions about those laws, he claimed I was engaging in a personal attack and deleted my comments.

He writes, “In that battle, guess who wins? The ALA. The children lose.”   As if the ALA was even involved in the battle! And how did the children lose? The unspoken, and unsubstantiated, claim is that children “lose” by having access to risqué graphic novels like Black Dossier.  Of course, he counts as nothing the First Amendment rights of minors to receive information.  Do children really win if, in our haste to protect them from age-inappropriate materials, we eliminate their Free Speech rights?  He enters into evidence not a single legal principle that would allow the library to restrict any minor's access to that book. 

He refers to Nobel Laureate Toni Morrison’s book The Bluest Eye as “the bestiality book.”  I reviewed that book on this blog, and found that it contained the WORD bestiality, but not the slightest description of any such act.  And when I called attention to his factual inaccuracy, he claimed I was trying to “besmirch” and “belittle” him, and deleted my comment as a personal attack.

He claims that “a community gets to decide for itself what is appropriate in its own public library.”  In fact, no such legal principle exists.  While the definition of obscenity is allowed to vary somewhat according to “community standards,” the Supreme Court has been quite clear that juries cannot push those standards to an infinite degree, and that materials like the Black Dossier book cannot be classified as obscene with regard to adults (see Jenkins v. Georgia).   SafeLibraries fails to comprehend that Free Speech rights are defined by the US Constitution and are NOT subject to arbitrary redefinition by states or localities.

His abuse of legal precedents reaches its peak in his handling of the Supreme Court’s US v. ALA decision, which upheld the federal government’s right to require internet filters on computers used by children as a condition attached to the acceptance of certain government funds.  SafeLibraries insists, relentlessly, that this case is some kind of major break with earlier Free Speech precedents, and no amount of quoting or explaining will snap him out of that utter delusion.  The US v. ALA decision says absolutely nothing of relevance to the Jessamine County library situation. 

I could go on and on, but I need to stop.

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

What SafeLibraries Doesn't Want You To Read.

Responding to posts on SafeLibraries' blog is often a dicey matter for me, since I find it very difficult to understand what he thinks does or does not constitute a personal attack.  He often accuses me of attacking him personally, when it appears to me I am only addressing the issues he's brought up.  Case in point is his post of Monday, November 9th, and my responses.  I only have some of that traffic, since he deleted my comments. You be the judge:

Non-Censor said...

Who is being unfair to whom? It is not fair of you to accuse me of personal attacks when all I have done is respond to the claims you yourself have made.
You DID say the firings took place overnight, and when I said you were incorrect about that I was not stating my personal opinion, but was referring to information provided in the Lexington Herald-Leader. I said so, and I provided a link to the article. 
You are right that we disagree greatly about the ALA, but I have no reason or desire to paint them as angels. I just don't see why you heap blame on an advisory organization for legal matters they have no regulatory control over, or local library decisions they did not make.
I suppose you could say the ALA indirectly supported this by suggesting to member libraries that they allow any patron to check out any non-obscene book. But that is not just ALA ideology, but a reasonable interpretation of Free Speech law.
My comments about the "bestiality" book were not meant to belittle or besmirch you in any way. YOU brought it up, linking to that in your main post. I never would have mentioned it if you hadn't tried to use it as evidence to support your position.
And you did not answer my question. What legal principle or precedent do you think would allow the citizens of Jessamine County do do as you suggest, to override the legal structure already laid out by local government, to override professionally trained librarians, to alter library policy to conform to "community view," and even replace the board if they stand in the way? And when all of that is said and done, what shape do you think the new library policies, conforming to "community views," can be? What existing law allows Black Dossier to be handled by any library in Kentucky in a way that is different from what has already been don?
Tue Nov 10, 10:49:00 PM 2009
And his response was:
SafeLibraries said...
I am removing the comments of "Non-Censor" as he has resorted to personal attack, my blog posts are filled with his personal attacks, I recently got him to address the issues, but he has returned to personal attack.
Tue Nov 10, 11:17:00 PM 2009

Monday, November 9, 2009

Jessamine County Situation Gets Much Clearer

In my October 29th post here, and on a page on www.bannedinwestbend.info, I called attention to the firing of two library employees at the Jessamine County public library in Kentucky.  The two employees prevented an 11-year-old patron from checking out a graphic novel called Black Dossier, which is part of the League of Extraordinary Gentlemen series.  The library employees took this action because they felt the book was pornographic or obscene.

Finally, some more incisive reportage has clarified some of the uncertainties in this situation.  In an article that appeared on Sunday, November 8th, the Lexington Herald-Leader dug into the details.

As I suspected, the fired employees were circulation desk attendants and not full librarians (it was difficult to imagine librarians taking the actions these employees took).  Also as suspected, their termination did not result from this isolated incident, but from over a year of resistance to library policies.  At least one of the fired employees had challenged the book in question, going through the formal challenge process.  After her challenge was considered and rejected, the employee checked the book out to herself and kept checking it out.  Apparently, she still has the book, and is now accumulating 10 cents a day in late charges.  The employee continues to deny wanting to keep the book away from adults, although that is exactly what she is doing.

As is all too typical of many cases of censorship, rhetoric and reality are two quite different things.  The fired employees continue to assert that the book meets some legal definition of obscenity, even though the library considered that possibility and rejected it.  As the Herald-Leader points out, Kentucky state law on obscenity contains specific exemptions with regard to public libraries, which is common (although not universal) in states across the country.   Having examined the book myself, I can say with some certainty that it is racy but not obscene.  They have gone so far as to assert  that the library may be committing some kind of felony by having or circulating the book, and yet they never contacted the police about this alleged crime, a pattern we've seen carried out over and over again by people who say a book is obscene but know they'd be filing a false police report if they took their own words seriously enough to act upon them.

Also typical of many cases, the fired employees are asserting that the local community is a "conservative" one, and that "community standards" define the book in question as obscene.  This, of course, is based on the quite mistaken notion that local communities have infinite leeway in defining what or is not obscene.  As I've recently pointed out on this blog, the Supreme Court has been quite clear that community standards are flexible but nowhere near that flexible.

In my opinion, the Jessamine County public library is to be commended both for allowing these employees to work through the legitimate challenge procedures and for firing them when they made it perfectly clear that they were interfering with the library's basic mission.